
Two nylon rods sit on the same supplier shelf: a 150 mm cast MC nylon rod and a 150 mm extruded PA66 rod. The cast one prices 20 to 40 percent lower per kilogram, and the sales argument writes itself — same polymer family, why pay more? The answer is that they are not the same material, and the per-kilogram comparison only means something after you know what each process does well. This note explains where the price difference comes from, what moves each quote, and when the cheaper kilogram is the wrong material for the job.
Where the price gap comes from
Cast MC nylon is polymerized in the mold: caprolactam monomer plus catalyst is poured into a heated tube or billet mold and polymerizes in place. The process needs little capital equipment, runs at atmospheric pressure, and one casting produces a large billet — 300, 400, even 500 mm diameter — that extrusion cannot reach at all. Low investment, low energy, huge parts: that is where the per-kilogram advantage comes from. Extruded PA66 pays for screw extrusion lines, pre-dried granulate, and smaller formats per pass, so its floor price is higher — but it delivers continuous lengths, tighter consistency along the bar, and the higher-temperature polymer itself.
| Factor | MC cast PA6 | Extruded PA66 |
|---|---|---|
| Typical price band, rod | Lowest per kg | Roughly 20–40 % higher |
| Maximum diameter | Up to ~500 mm billets | Usually ≤ 200 mm |
| Continuous lengths | Short, cast-to-size | Metres per bar |
| Strength and modulus | Good | Higher |
| Heat resistance | ~100 °C continuous | ~120–130 °C continuous |
| Moisture uptake | Higher (PA6 base) | Lower (PA66 base) |
| Consistency along the bar | Batch-dependent | Tighter |
What actually moves each quote
Diameter, in opposite directions. For cast MC, bigger is cheaper per kilogram: large billets spread casting cost over more material, and the price curve flattens above 100 mm. For extruded PA66, bigger is more expensive per kilogram: large extrusion runs slower and warps more, so every step up in diameter adds cost. A 40 mm PA66 rod can price close to its cast MC counterpart; a 200 mm PA66 rod prices far above cast MC — if it is offered at all.
Grade adders. Oil-filled MC (MC901 type), heat-stabilized, and pigmented versions add a modest percentage to cast prices. PA66 adders run higher: glass-filled PA66 GF30 prices noticeably above natural, and food or medical documentation adds more on both sides.
Certification and origin. Food-contact declarations, batch traceability and brand-name stock (KETRON, ERTALYTE, SUSTAMID) move both quotes upward. Parallel-import and mill-direct material move them down; verify what documentation you are actually buying.
Volume and cutting. Full bars price better than cut blanks everywhere. If your machining plan allows taking full stock lengths, the per-kilogram number drops on both materials — often more than the cast-versus-extruded gap itself.
When the cheaper kilogram is the wrong material
The per-kilogram saving of cast MC evaporates in four situations. First, temperature: above roughly 100 °C continuous, PA6 loses strength fast while PA66 keeps working to 120–130 °C. Second, moisture-critical dimensions: PA6 absorbs more water than PA66 at the same humidity, so a precision PA6 part drifts more — if tolerances are tight and the environment is humid, the cheaper rod becomes the expensive rework. Third, fatigue and impact cycling: PA66’s higher crystallinity and strength hold up better under repeated loading. Fourth, precision small diameter: for rods under about 40 mm where consistency along the length matters, extruded PA66 avoids the batch variation of cast stock.
Conversely, cast MC is the correct answer in plenty of cases: large rollers, sheaves, gears above module 4, wear pads and bearing blocks in the 80–200 mm range, where its price advantage is largest and its property set — good strength, good wear, huge section — is exactly what the part needs. In that zone the PA66 quotation is not a better deal; it is a worse one that happens to cost more.
How to compare two quotes correctly
Confirm the density you are being charged. Both nylons are around 1.15 g/cm³, so per-kilogram comparisons are fair — but confirm the seller prices by actual weight, not a nominal weight table. Some quotes assume a heavier bar than they deliver.
Confirm process and grade in writing. “Nylon rod” alone is meaningless. Ask for cast PA6 / extruded PA66 on the quotation, plus the grade (oil-filled? stabilized? filled?) and the moisture condition at machining — cast stock is often supplied in a humid state that will shrink slightly after drying.
Check roundness and tolerance on large cast diameters. Cast billets over 200 mm can carry ovality and shrinkage surprises. If your part takes a bearing seat on the OD, agree a machining allowance and tolerance before ordering, not after.
Compare cut-to-length prices when your machine time matters. A pre-cut blank with the right oversize can cost slightly more per kilogram and still win total cost, because you drop the sawing step and the offcut scrap.
Questions we answer weekly
Is cast MC nylon weaker than PA66? In absolute strength, slightly — PA66 typically runs 10 to 20 percent higher on tensile. But above module 4 gear sizes and bearing blocks, the part is stiffness- and wear-governed, where the gap matters little. For thin precision features, PA66’s strength edge becomes real.
Why is one supplier’s MC rod 40 % cheaper than another’s? Hydrolyzed-monomer content, mold quality and post-curing discipline vary widely between casters. Very cheap cast stock shows itself as internal porosity and premature wear — ask for the casting method and, for critical parts, an ultrasonic check on the first batch.
Can I substitute one for the other in an existing design? Only after checking temperature, moisture environment and load type. The two polymers behave differently enough that a swap can change clearances within a season.
Need a material recommendation?
Send us the application and we will reply with two or three candidate grades and a price.
